Study finds EPC RFID ROI is MIA

T

he results of ARC Advisory Group Emerging Practices study, which surveyed 24 companies actively investing in Electronic Product Code Radio Frequency Identification (EPC RFID), found that only one company believed it could achieve a less than two-year payback on its investment. A full 95% of the respondents believed the payback period would take more than two years.

The study imagines a company that ships 50 million cases a year to Wal-Mart. Even at 20 cents/tag—a very optimistic assumption—that represents a $10 million hit. Add to that a million dollars in expenses to prepare the RFID infrastructure, says the report, and perhaps another half a million dollars in new labor costs. This company would therefore need to generate about $11.5 million dollars in new savings merely to break even.

The study further imagines that this company’s analysis of potential payback buckets shows they might generate a million dollars in lower chargeback fees, if Wal-Mart cooperates with them, and that the other savings buckets could come to, at most, a half a million dollars. The analysts say this story is typical of the kind of story they heard during their interview process.

Wal-Mart has mandated that by January 2005 its top 100 suppliers must apply passive RFID tags based on EPC-global standards to cases and pallets headed toward three distribution centers in Texas. Those companies affected are unlikely to try passing along these costs to Wal-Mart. It’s more likely they’ll try to raise prices to their retail customers instead.

The study, mirroring industry reactions, states that virtually all manufacturers of consumer goods will eventually be impacted by this because Wal-Mart’s moves in RFID are being copied by other retailers. Unfortunately for manufacturers and distributors selling to large retailers, RFID has a much lower ROI for them than for their retail customers. According to Steve Banker, ARC service director for supply chain management, “The situation is made more difficult because the technology is immature and current suppliers of tags are unreliably supplying a poor quality product.”

Even though respondents to the ARC study almost universally believe that EPC RFID has a poor ROI, companies facing RFID mandates are actively searching for benefits that can mitigate program costs. It is also true, says the report, that many Wal-Mart suppliers believe that, while certain areas have the potential for savings, they will not, in many cases, be able to actually reap these savings for several years.

The industry is in wide agreement that certain conditions have to be realized:
1.  The reliability of reads needs to improve greatly
2.  The cost of tags has to drop
3.  A critical mass of retailers have to act on RFID mandates

Another factor, says the report is that more efficient warehouse receiving and better management of inbound materials may have to wait until companies have been able to negotiate with their upstream suppliers to engage in more RFID tagging.



MAIN POTENTIAL BENEFITS FROM EPC RFID
Warehouse Eficiencies -- 45%
Less Inventory -- 27%
Deductions -- 27%
Traceability/Recalls -- 23%
In Stock Position -- 18%
Improved Service -- 9%
Shipping Costs -- 9%
Supplier Management -- 5%

More News:

  • China Adopts EtherCAT as a National Technology Standard

    Chinese company representatives shared experiences about their numerous EtherCAT systems and applications with the audience and explained the benefits realized through implementation.

  • HART-Fieldbus Foundation Marriage Complete

    The final step in constructing a single organization to lead process automation communications and integration technologies was completed at the end of August when the members of both the HART Communication Foundation and Fieldbus Foundation approved the merger proposed by their respective boards.

  • Use of BYOD Spreads, But Holdouts Remain

    Manufacturing workers are jumping on the bring-your-own-device (BYOD) bandwagon,

  • ISA100 Wireless Standard Gains Final IEC Approval

    ANSI/ISA-100.11a-2011, "Wireless Systems for Industrial Automation: Process Control and Related Applications," has been unanimously approved by the IEC as an international standard

  • Mergers, Acquisitions & Alliances: Danfoss Makes Offer, Hardinge Acquires Assets, and Fanuc and Rockwell Collaborate

    Danfoss made a public tender offer for all shares of the Finnish ac drives company Vacon. Hardinge, international provider of advanced metal-cutting solutions, agreed to acquire the assets of the Voumard internal diameter (ID) grinding business from Peter Wolters GmbH in Rendsburg, Germany. Maverick Technologies, acquired CQS Innovation, a system integrator specializing in control and information systems for life sciences, chemical and metals industries.

  • Belden Advocates Ethernet, Security and Wireless

    The Internet of Things (IoT) and the industrial IoT will use increasingly intelligent network infrastructures, but this will create more risk and increase the need to protect those critical infrastructures and their data. That's why we're investing both organically and through acquisition in Ethernet, security and wireless—so we can help transform this interconnected world.

  • The Future Is Forged at IMTS 2014

    Front and center was large-scale additive manufacturing in the form of the world's first 3D-printed car, which was printed and assembled on-site at the show. The project was a cooperative effort by Local Motors, Cincinnati Inc.; Oak Ridge National Laboratory; the University of Tennessee; and IMTS' Association for Manufacturing Technology (AMT).

  • Big Manufacturing Trade-Shows Dominate November Calendar

    There Will be More than 100 Exhibits Featuring Products and Services from Rockwell Automation and its Network of more than 100 Partners.

  • Honeywell OneWireless Takes the Prize for Best Wireless Solution

    The OneWireless Network is designed to enhance efficiency, safety and reliability in business processes. The OneWireless Network offers flexibility and scalability, wire-like performance with wireless security and best-in-class data availability with a low cost of ownership.

  • The Center for Compact and Efficient Fluid Power Hosts International Conference on Workforce Skills Transforming the Fluid Power Industry

    A panel session, featuring Vanderbilt University's Chancellor Nicholas Zeppos and Dean of Engineering Philippe Fauchet, will focus on the future of public-private partnerships in innovation, high-technology workforce skills, and ways to accelerate the transition of research to the marketplace.

All news »

What are your comments?

Join the discussion today. Login Here.

Comments

No one has commented on this page yet.

RSS feed for comments on this page | RSS feed for all comments