Voices: Reader Feedback

Reader Feedback: R.I.P. PLC?

The PLC May Be On the Verge of Extinction as a Hardware Proposition

By Steve Meyer

Great to see your March 2014 piece on the PLC ("Live Wire," p. 17 ). Quite a statement. This is something I have been saying for some time, although coming from a slightly different context. I got dragged into a silicon start-up specializing in embedded motor control and got exposed to the power and cost of these devices. Five years ago it was possible to make a PLC work on a $6 processor with Ethernet already built into it.

The PLC may be on the verge of extinction as a hardware proposition. The fact that CoDeSys has pretty well co-oped the entire industry is nothing short of amazing. So now that the logic is software-based, there's not much market basis that will sustain hardware. The only thing that will endure is the need for I/O and the ability to host the application for the point of use. How that is implemented can be anything if the application is software-based.

Also Read: Are PLCs' Days Numbered?

The other thing to factor in is the ladder diagramming language. We've predicted the demise of ladder logic for decades. And it's still here with us. Too much installed base and no obvious replacement.

Manufacturers using the cloud? I don't think this is likely on individual machines. Plant network? Yeah. Corporate IT? Hell, yeah. Why pay for owning all that overhead if someone will host it for you for cheap?
Thanks for taking the risk to say it, I am impressed with your candor. The industry needs more honesty. Let's give it to them.

Steve Meyer
Senior Consultant,
Solid Tech Inc.

More From This Voice

Title

Reader Feedback: R.I.P. PLC?

The PLC May Be On the Verge of Extinction as a Hardware Proposition

05/06/2014

Reader Feedback: Readers Remember When They Bought Their First Home Computer

A Reader Recalls First Encounter With a Burroughs B3500

04/08/2014

Reader Feedback: Lithium Batteries and Electric Cars

A Reader Disagrees With Our Editor On All Fronts About Lithium Batteries and Electric Cars

04/08/2014

Reader Feedback: Graphene? Carbon Nanotubes? Ultracapacitors?

We'll See Energy Storage Made Better Very Shortly

04/08/2014

Reader Feedback: Automation and Employees

Why Is There a General Perception That Robots and Automation Always Mean a Reduced Head Count?

04/05/2013

Reader Feedback: A Key Factor of Motivation

It Depends on a Manger's Perspective on the Importance of Others vs. Self

04/05/2013

Reader Feedback: The PC-to-PLC Name Transition

Our Reader First Saw "PLC" Used by Allen-Bradley to Distinguish Its Product From DCSs

10/04/2012

Reader Feedback: Get Some IT Help to Protect Your SCADA System

Our Reader Addresses Their Concern for Many of Their Customers' Control System Security (or Lack of It)

10/04/2012

Reader Feedback: Handheld HMI Pitfalls

A Reader Thinks Handheld Wireless Controls Can Be Good for the Workplace, but Must Be Monitored by the Company

09/05/2012

Reader Feedback: Know Your Whole Operating System

A Reader Agrees With Our Editor That Owners Must Be Educated on the System, Not Just the Control

08/16/2012

Reader Feedback: Automation Jobs and Third-World Ingenuity

A Reader Disagrees With Our Editor That Lack of Respect or Low Pay Deters Young People From Entering Technical Fields

08/16/2012

Reader Feedback: Time for Team Building

The Conflicting Relationship Between Business IT vs. Control Engineers

08/16/2012

Reader Feedback: What the L?

A Reader Reflects on Our Articles 'PLC Genesis', 'The History of the PLC' and 'History of Control; History of PLC and DCS'

08/16/2012

Reader Feedback: Arc Flash Really So Common?

Where Did We Get Our Statistics on Electrical Accidents?

06/14/2012

Reader Feedback: Technical Support - Competing With Free

If The Major Players Didn't Charge for the Software or Support, We Would Struggle Kicking Them Out of Accounts

06/14/2012

Reader Feedback: Turn On the Right Alarm

Designing an Alarm and Monitoring System or an Operating System Are in No Way the Same Thing

11/07/2011

Reader Feedback: STEM Jobs - A Career in Law?

Volatility of STEM Jobs. The Technical Ranks Within Company Are the First Ones to Get Cut in Tough Financial Times

11/07/2011

Reader Feedback: Throw Out What We've Learned

The Concept of Mainstreaming Is Killing America's Educational System

10/05/2011

Reader Feedback: Disposable Workers

Blue Collar Workers Made America What It Is--Well What It Used to Be

10/05/2011

Reader Feedback: Manufacturing Jobs - All or Nothing

There Is So Much Competition in the Manufacturing Industry That We Are All Having Difficulties Hiring

10/05/2011