Shale Gas Can Be More Disastrous Than Coal if Not Controlled

According to recent debate, the stance on energy still varies greatly. While some people are of the belief that natural gas is the newest and best thing that can do no wrong, others are not shy about voicing their sheer disgust.

The oil and gas executives pride themselves on this new energy source praising the abundance of natural gas that is released from underground shale deposits, and is extracted from the earth by a combination of horizontal and hydraulic fracturing.

But while natural gas offers alternatives to oil and gas, it is not free from considerations.

Yes, natural gas lowers energy costs, creates new jobs and boosts domestic manufacturing industries in the U.S., as well as carries some environmental advantages.  But.  And there is a rather large “but.”

When natural gas is burned, the amount of toxic air pollutants, such as sulfur dioxide and mercury, are only produced in miniscule amounts compared to coal.  But no process is fail-proof. 

It is obvious while natural gas supporters rave about natural gas. Air quality is not as compromised like that of coal when it is burned, leading to better rates of public health.  Also, the climate is protected as natural gas only emits approximately half the carbon dioxide as burned coal does.

But, and here is where the large “but” comes in:

Shale gas extraction has in many cases caused real-life problems for residents in areas where localized air and groundwater becomes polluted.  This happens when mistakes or carelessness creeps into the construction area and results in spills or other accidents. A small town in Wyoming called Pinedale, is one such town.

And while natural gas produces only half the amount of carbon dioxide as coal when burned, uncombusted natural gas is essentially methane. And if not properly regulated, methane is 84 times more potent than that of carbon dioxide for 20 years after it is released.

The question is not whether we can prevent methane emissions, but do we want to?

Read the full New York Times article here.

More News:

  • Patent Dispute Settled Between Rockwell Automation and Beckhoff Automation

    Rockwell Automation's linear motor business, including its recent Jacobs Automation acquisition, has developed a substantial portfolio of patents comprising over 100 issued patents on linear motor technology alone.

  • Mergers, Acquisitions Alliances and Noteworthy News in Robotics

    Iten Industries, manufacturer of advanced composite components and materials headquartered in Ashtabula, Ohio, is now offering additive manufacturing and 3D printing services.

  • U.S. Economy Looks Up for Manufacturing Industries

    The August PMI is led by the highest recorded New Orders Index since April 2004, when it registered 67.1%.

  • ASME Forum Ignites 21st-Century Engineering

    Founder and president of HMI/SCADA software developer Iconics, Russ Agrusa, said the company is focusing on how to harness big data on any device and in any class of applications, and turn it into predictive analytics in manufacturing and business intelligence.

  • New Customer Care Center for Endress+Hauser

    To help customers keep up with today's challenges, Endress+Hauser's new, state-of-the-art Customer Center is suited to greet visitors with a top-notch certified training facility with multiple classrooms and its largest yet PTU controlled by Rockwell Automation's PlantPAx system for real-world process simulation with over 120 measuring points.

  • The Rise of Aluminum in the Industrial Sector

    It is not just price that makes aluminum appealing when put alongside copper in the production of items like electrical wires and cables, though.

  • Maverick Acquires CQS Innovation Expanding Process Expertise in the Life Sciences Industry

    The acquisition expands Maverick's size and scale as a global organization with 19 office locations and 500+ engineering professionals. In addition, Chris Roerig, current president of CQS Innovation, will join Maverick as industry manager for life sciences.

  • ISA Offers Cybersecurity Certificate Program

    The program consists of passing a course on using the ANSI/ISA-62443 standards to secure industrial control systems. The course is available in the classroom or online. Students must also pass a written exam in the classroom or online.

  • Fieldbus Groups 'Unite'

    The combined power of both organizations will aim to protect the investments that end users in process automation have made in HART and Foundation fieldbus communication technologies.

  • Guess Who Just Turned 125 Years Old?

    ABB recently celebrated its 125th anniversary in Finland.

All news »

What are your comments?

Join the discussion today. Login Here.


No one has commented on this page yet.

RSS feed for comments on this page | RSS feed for all comments