Screw Clamp or IDC Terminal Connectors -- Which Works Better?

Experts Help a Reader Decide: Screw-Clamp or IDC?

1 of 2 < 1 | 2 View on one page

We first published this terminal block discussion in the November 2003 issue. It seems to be a pretty timeless piece that's well-suited for our anniversary look back at the content we've produced during the past 15 years.



A Reader Writes:

Until recently, for better or worse, we used screw-clamp terminal blocks for connections. Now, we have customers that prefer and sometimes specify insulation-displacement connectivity. They argue IDC means lower installation costs and reduced cabinet space as a result. That's fine, but I'd like to hear what real users know about the increased likelihood of having to run down loose connections in the field later on. We sell into global environments with varying degrees of vibration, repetitive motion, etc.

—From August Control Design

Answers

Use Cage-Clamp When Free to Choose
We have switched to cage-clamp terminals for our unspecified control panels. One of our toughest customers is a road construction equipment builder. We design and fabricate the control panels for them. This equipment is very high vibration and must work in temps ranging from 0-100° F-plus.

Sales reps have been telling us that IDC terminals have improved and are the way to go. We built a test panel to mount on a piece of road equipment. It did not do anything. We just had a few 120 VAC and 24 VDC circuits that had lamps on them. We used both cage-clamp and IDC terminals. At the end of three months, we had an 8% failure of the IDC terminals and a 0% failure on the cage-clamps. At the end of one year, 19% of the IDC terminal connections had failed and 0% of the cage-clamps had failed. By failed, I mean the circuit was open completely or intermittently.

Steve Clayton,
Motor Control Engineering LLC

IDC Will Do Fine
We have a considerable amount of experience with our IDC terminal blocks used in industrial environments. The applications range from connections to PLCs and other control systems, marshalling cabinets located throughout the plant, motor control centers, test equipment, HVAC wiring, security and energy management wiring, and local control panels in the plants, to a wide variety of instrumentation.

Regarding where not to locate IDC terminations, the only obvious prohibition would be where the temperature environment would exceed the temperature range of the terminal block, which would be the same requirement of any type of terminal block including screw clamp or spring clamp). The IDC terminal block is designed to meet IEC 947-7-1, the international standard for all IEC types of terminal blocks.

The terminal block housing should be designed such that the housing provides insulation support on both sides of the termination contact, thereby protecting the wire connection in the event of vibration (1 in figure).

The contact should provide a gas-tight connection, which is necessary to stand up to the environments in an industrial application with corrosion or contact problems, to provide years of reliable operation (2 in figure). The contact should be designed to eliminate any potential damage to stranded wire during wire termination. In the case of our connector, the contact is at a 45° angle to the wire, eliminating any potential problems while ensuring a constant axial force on the wire during the life of the termination (3 in figure). The contact should be made out of a special spring-type copper alloy and should be nickel-plated to provide a high-quality electrical connection and prevent any problems associated with corrosion. The contact should be designed to be reterminated multiple times without deformation to the contact area.

The terminal block should have test reports validating the ability to stand up in areas of vibration, corrosion, and current-carrying capability and should include a wide range of international approvals such as UL, CSA, DEMKO, SEMKO, FINKO, Lloyds, etc.

Howard Minnick,
President,
Automation Systems Interconnect, www.asi-ez.com

 

IDC Saves Money
IDC technology is designed to save up to 60% of installation time and can be terminated with no special tools or stripping of the conductors. You should look for connections between the contact and the wire to be gas-tight. This ensures a reliable solution over time in harsh environments.

The contact should have good corrosion resistance, so look for a metal body that is plated copper alloy. The IDC contact should be manufactured in a shock-proof housing to prevent electrical shock or shorting. It should be designed to industry standard pin spacing and be capable of withstanding industrial currents and voltages.

1 of 2 < 1 | 2 View on one page
Show Comments
Hide Comments

Join the discussion

We welcome your thoughtful comments.
All comments will display your user name.

Want to participate in the discussion?

Register for free

Log in for complete access.

Comments

No one has commented on this page yet.

RSS feed for comments on this page | RSS feed for all comments