IEC-61131 is a ‘NON-Standard’

    Sept. 12, 2007
    True, it is a 'standard', but for whom? Users?? I think not. While it allows for vendors to write 'compliant' products, who says they ARE compliant? No one. PLCopen (for which I was the managing director for 7 years) has tried to develop testing for compliance but who really cares? Compliancy is ONLY good for and needed by a community that requires portability between code. If not then its no different than the good ol' days of Modicon vs Allen-Bradley. Regardless of the benefits (if any for the user base), being IEC-compliant doesnt mean a damn thing. The PLC programming environment you use is there because of the hardware you use. Do you CARE that it IEC-61131 compliant? Would you switch hardware vendors to get IEC-61131 compliant software? Rant over :) Flak jacket on - ready for input.
    True, it is a 'standard', but for whom? Users?? I think not. While it allows for vendors to write 'compliant' products, who says they ARE compliant? No one. PLCopen (for which I was the managing director for 7 years) has tried to develop testing for compliance but who really cares? Compliancy is ONLY good for and needed by a community that requires portability between code. If not then its no different than the good ol' days of Modicon vs Allen-Bradley. Regardless of the benefits (if any for the user base), being IEC-compliant doesnt mean a damn thing. The PLC programming environment you use is there because of the hardware you use. Do you CARE that it IEC-61131 compliant? Would you switch hardware vendors to get IEC-61131 compliant software? Rant over :) Flak jacket on - ready for input.
    About the Author

    Jeremy Pollard | CET

    Jeremy Pollard, CET, has been writing about technology and software issues for many years. Pollard has been involved in control system programming and training for more than 25 years.

    Continue Reading

    Sponsored Recommendations

    Programmable logic controllers (PLCs) and programmable automation controllers (PACs) provide viable options for machine control. This Control Design collection explains the differences...
    Motion control engineers tend to focus on torque and speed specifications during the design process, but often fail to notice the unique features that differentiate a high-quality...
    Covering the basics of choosing the right position feedback option for your application.
    This white paper describes advantages of using advanced angle sensor technologies and focuses on best practices for correctly implementing non-­contact and touchless angle sensors...

    Latest from Home

    Most Read

    Sponsored