How to actuate in dirty, wet environments

Expert panel offers suggestions on installing linear motion in messy machine areas

By Mike Bacidore, editor in chief

Dirty, wet machine environments can be the source of headaches, especially when you're implementing linear motion. The technology can bring accuracy and precision to many applications, but selecting components for messy areas requires a bit of forethought. Our panel of industry experts cleans up the information landscape with some pointers.

Related report: Benefits of Programmable Linear Position Sensors

How can I install a linear motion actuator in a dirty, wet machine environment?

Broc GrellBroc Grell, Nexen Group: Most high precision motion systems need some sort of cover like a bellows. Tricks such as mounting the rack teeth down or teeth sideways allows for debris to not get stuck in the teeth. A stainless option or a thermoplastic for washdown applications or other harsh environments can be used where smoothness is key but accuracy is not as important.

Broc Grell is applications engineer at Nexen Group.

 

Clint HayesClint Hayes, Bosch Rexroth: In environments with high humidity and/or moisture, options for corrosion resistance include stainless steel or specialty anti-corrosion plating, such as thin dense chrome (TDC) or nickel alloy coating.

In harsh environments, for example, where metal or wood shavings may be present, tested and proven sealing technology for linear motion components is imperative if you wish to achieve the full service life from a bearing system. A good sealing function will keep lubrication preserved within the bearing and keep contamination out of the system (Figure 1). What makes for a good seal? Full interference contact around the perimeter of the component and material that is impervious to the surrounding contaminants.

Clint Hayes is product sales manager, linear motion technology at Bosch Rexroth.

Chris BullockChris Bullock, Bishop-Wisecarver Group: The main concern would be the debris on the mounting surface, which could result in an unstable mounting situation. It would be best to clean that and then mount your actuator to the surface. If you can’t, for whatever reason, then you may be able to attach the actuator loosely and then slowly tighten down while using water or air to remove the dirt/debris from under it as you lower it.

Chris Bullock is applications engineer I at Bishop-Wisecarver Group.

 

Gary RosengrenGary Rosengren, Tolomatic: Dusty environments that require linear-motion devices are relatively common. For example, dust generated from paper or corrugated cardboard materials, textiles or normal factory air tends to be dry and relatively light in weight. Most rod-type linear actuators can perform in this type of environment without adverse effects. The addition of rod wipers will further enhance the actuator’s ability to keep dust from its internal components, as well as retain the lubrication present inside the actuator. Rodless actuators also can perform well in this type of environment, as many include a type of cover strip that shields internal components from dust ingress (Figure 2).

Rodless actuators may be enhanced by the addition of a positive pressure port on the body of the actuator designed to equalize internal and external pressures and help to keep dust away from possible ingress points. In dusty applications, IP54 would be the minimum rating to consider. An actuator with an IP54 rating is protected from dust (5) and splashing water (4), even though splashing water may not be present. In extremely dusty conditions where there are materials being cut, such as in woodworking, or light metal machining and light grinding, the accumulation of dust tends to be considerably heavier. In these applications, a higher rating such as IP65 should be considered, making the device dust-tight (6) and protected from low pressure—4.4 psi—jets of water. Even though there may not be water in the environment, the sealing mechanism for dust exclusion is typically effective for that level of low-pressure water protection. Rod-type actuators that have rod wipers or rod seals also perform well in these conditions; however, rodless actuators typically do not perform well unless some kind of custom-designed protection is applied. Custom-designed protection is best provided by the machinery manufacturer.

In applications where water is present, it is important to fully understand the source, direction and volume of the water to which the actuator will be subjected. For example, consider a system in which an actuator is reciprocating a spray head that is directed away from the actuator toward the processed product. Inevitably, some of the water, mist or water vapor will settle back on the actuator. The actuator therefore should have a level of protection against splashing water or against low-pressure jets (Figure 3). Since the sealing mechanism of most rod-type actuators consists of a rod wiper or rod seal, actuators with a rating of IP65 would be satisfactory. Rodless actuators will experience water ingress at some point unless custom-designed shields or guards are applied.

When an actuator is required to be directly in the path of water—for example, the actuator is moving product within the range of sprayed water—additional ingress protection is required. IP66- or IP67-rated devices may be more appropriate in this case. Devices with these higher IP ratings will typically have redundant exclusion mechanisms such as shields, bellows or guards, ensuring long-term functionality. Again, rodless actuators will not perform well in these applications without customized protection (Figure 4).

Another common industrial application for actuators is on equipment that requires aggressive cleaning. Equipment used in the preparation of foods and beverages often requires frequent and specific cleaning procedures. In these cases, actuator protection requirements are particularly stringent because food and beverage equipment is often cleaned with aggressive detergent solutions, as well as washed and rinsed with hot 180-°F, high-pressure 1,500-psi water spray or steam. When specifying actuators for applications such as these, there are two important considerations.

  1. Understand the chemical makeup of the cleaning solutions. For example, the effects of very high or very low pH cleaning solutions on various components need to be fully understood, so the materials used for the sealing mechanism are compatible and do not degrade. This also requires that the metal materials used in the construction of the actuator body be resistant to the particular cleaning solutions.
  2. Specify sealing materials that are compatible with the cleaning chemicals and resistant to high-pressure and high-temperature water spray. Actuators with a rating of IP69K are best suited for this type of environment. However, it is always wise to perform testing on the solutions used in the process to ensure chemical compatibility. Applications involving chemical solutions need to be treated somewhat differently than applications involving simple water ingress. IP ratings do not imply chemical compatibility. Knowing exactly which chemicals the actuator will be exposed to will help the actuator supplier select materials most likely to offer good service life. Important factors to consider are the chemical makeup of the solution being used, its concentration level, duration of exposure to components to which it is applied and operating temperatures. This information is critical to applying linear actuators in these types of applications to ensure proper functionality and longevity.

Gary Rosengren is director of engineering at Tolomatic.

Derrick StaceyDerrick Stacey, B&R Industrial Automation: We approach this environment using two main features of the SuperTrak. First, the SuperTrak is fully potted so the magnetic coils are completely sealed and the electronics boards are sealed in an IP65 cabinet on each motor section. This means we can handle noncorrosive liquid spills and overspray from material removal processes.

The second feature that allows SuperTrak to withstand nontraditional linear-motion environments is the mover/pallet design. The movers are held in place by magnetism and are guided with simple rolling elements. This means we can simply shield each mover with a slightly oversized cover to protect the rolling elements and minimize the debris build up on the vertical track face. The magnetic hold is important because there is an inherent air gap between the magnet and the coils in the motor sections, so even a few-millimeter layer of debris and film would not affect the control and dynamics of the system.

Derrick Stacey is solutions engineer at B&R Industrial Automation. 

Jeremy Miller thumbJeremy Miller, Parker Hannifin: Designing for harsh environments such as wet or dirty atmospheres with linear motion can be a challenging venture. Traditionally, with respect to linear actuation, this is addressed in one of two ways. The first is finding ways to mitigate the buildup and/or pooling of these contaminants within the actuator. Techniques such as designing drainage into the system or integrating labyrinth-style designs to reduce ingress of contamination into the system are common approaches. This is often the cost-effective approach and allows for some ingress into the actuator but works to prevent buildup. For this to work, component elements must be durable to prevent corrosion or premature failure.

 

The second common approach is to use actuators that were designed specifically with high levels of ingress-protection (IP) sealing. Traditionally, electric cylinders are able to achieve higher levels of IP, with levels up to IP69K. This prevents all liquid and solid contamination into the actuator. Additionally, these cylinders are often designed with positive external geometry to prevent microbial growth and pooling on the surface. Also, stainless-steel materials prevent contamination. With rodless actuators, effective sealing is often more challenging, given the form factor.

Jeremy Miller is product manager—linear mechanics at Parker Hannifin's Electromechanical & Drives Division.

Jay JohnsonJay Johnson, Sick: Selecting the correct components for the environment is crucial in order to avoid the negative effects of corrosion, oxidation and contamination. Additional guarding or sealing could also be required depending on the type of exposure. When in doubt, cover it. An attempt to save money on proper guarding often results in much more costly downtime, and it is important to recognize that a high IP rating doesn’t necessarily ensure a component is suited for a continuously wet environment. For instance, an aluminum device rated IP67 will eventually oxidize if exposed steadily to water spray, even if only indirect or at low pressure. Oxidation sooner or later allows ingress. Therefore, covering the device or selecting a model made of stainless steel, or other appropriate material, is required for longevity.

Focusing on position feedback devices, when installed correctly a dirty and wet machine environment will not affect the signal quality of a linear magnetic encoder in the same way as that of an optical sensor.

Jay Johnson is national product manager at Sick.

 

Show Comments
Hide Comments

Join the discussion

We welcome your thoughtful comments.
All comments will display your user name.

Want to participate in the discussion?

Register for free

Log in for complete access.

Comments

No one has commented on this page yet.

RSS feed for comments on this page | RSS feed for all comments