Hardwired vs. networked functional safety: What machine builders need to know

Beyond safe torque off: How to design safer, smarter machine control systems

Functional safety is a critical consideration for machine builders and system integrators, but determining the appropriate safety architecture involves much more than selecting a safety-rated programmable logic controller (PLC), variable-frequency drive (VFD) or relay. Sneha Mahajan, senior application engineer, control products, at NORD Drivesystems, discusses the fundamentals of functional safety, safety instrumented systems and safety integrity levels (SILs), explaining how risk assessments establish the requirements for protecting personnel and equipment. She explores how controls engineers can determine whether conventional hardwired safety circuits are sufficient or whether networked functional safety over industrial Ethernet offers advantages, particularly for larger machines and complex material-handling systems.

Mahajan examines drive-based safety functions, including safe torque off (STO), safe stop 1 (SS1), safely limited speed (SLS) and safe speed monitoring, explaining why STO alone might not provide adequate protection for applications requiring predictable deceleration or controlled stopping, particularly when regenerative energy must be dissipated through equipment such as dynamic braking resistors. She also addresses the capabilities and limitations of encoderless safety monitoring, including why applications involving lifting or sustained regenerative operation can present challenges. For machine builders, these considerations reinforce the importance of evaluating the complete mechanical and electrical system rather than relying exclusively on the safety ratings of individual components.

Networked functional safety is another major focus, with particular attention to how safety communications over industrial Ethernet can improve machine commissioning, troubleshooting and recovery following safety events. Mahajan explains how protocols such as ProfiSafe, Fail Safe over EtherCAT (FSoE) and CIP Safety use the black-channel principle to transmit safety-critical information over conventional network infrastructure. Unlike traditional hardwired circuits that might provide only basic on/off status, networked safety systems can deliver device-level diagnostic information that helps maintenance personnel identify faults and minimize downtime. The conversation concludes by examining the challenges of standardizing machine safety architectures across different PLC and industrial networking platforms, including Profinet, EtherCAT and EtherNet/IP, as well as the potential benefits of more open engineering environments.

Chapters

  • 0:00 - Functional Safety, SIS, and SIL
  • 03:20 - Hardwired Safety vs. Functional Safety
  • 06:02 - Safe Torque Off (STO) Deep Dive
  • 08:03 - Risk Assessments and Translating Scores to Hardware Architecture
  • 13:38 - Networked Safety Commissioning & Diagnostics
  • 17:02 - The Black Channel Principle
  • 19:04 - Encoderless Safe Speed Monitoring
  • 22:12 - Machines Across Multiple Ethernet Protocols
  • 26:50 - Open-Source Automation

About the Author

Mike Bacidore

Mike Bacidore

Editor in Chief

Mike Bacidore is chief editor of Control Design and has been an integral part of the Endeavor Business Media editorial team since 2007. Previously, he was editorial director at Hughes Communications and a portfolio manager of the human resources and labor law areas at Wolters Kluwer. Bacidore holds a BA from the University of Illinois and an MBA from Lake Forest Graduate School of Management. He is an award-winning columnist, earning multiple regional and national awards from the American Society of Business Publication Editors. He may be reached at [email protected] 

Sign up for our eNewsletters
Get the latest news and updates